EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Crossref

The hollow newel state in gastropods: when snail shells are open-axis

Dana S Friend, Brendan M Anderson, Warren D Allmon

Journal of Molluscan Studies · 13.01.2024 · 90 (1)

DOI: 10.1093/mollus/eyae001 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Journal of Molluscan Studies, online erschienen am 23.02.2024. Verfasst von Dana S Friend und 2 weiteren Autor:innen. Die Arbeit wurde bisher 3-mal zitiert (Crossref) und nennt 38 Literaturangaben. Gefördert von: National Science Foundation.

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

Holes are an interesting topic in philosophy. In common experience, they are treated as things—referential objects, equal to material objects. Yet they can also be viewed as the absence of something, and so it may be argued that holes do not exist, and that all statements putatively about holes are actually about holed objects (Casati & Varzi, 2019). Nevertheless, the absence of something expected can have a significant impact (Goldschmidt, 2016). Holes can also present practical nomenclatural problems in zoological morphology. Descriptions of gastropod shells commonly include at least two kinds of ‘holes’: the opening in which the body is located (the aperture) and openings associated with the axial (or columellar) region. These axial openings, however, have not always been treated or labelled consistently, and this inconsistency has obscured a thorough analysis of the diversity of this part of gastropod shell form. Recent investigation of previously unrecognized openings in fossil turritellid gastropods (Friend et al., 2023) has prompted us to review this diversity across all gastropods, and to describe a new structural condition of the axial (columellar) region, which we herein label a ‘hollow newel’ (HN). A coiled shell is a conical tube wrapped in a spiral around a central, usually straight, axis (Raup, 1966). In a helically coiled shell, if there is no space between successive coils (whorls), then the inward-facing walls of the tube are in contact, and form a structure along or surrounding that axis, termed the columella in gastropods. The columella stretches from the shell apex to either the midpoint of the base or undersurface (abapical end) of the shell or the end of the siphonal canal, and is not usually visible except for the newest growth at the abapical end of the shell that can be seen as part of the aperture and/or anterior siphonal canal (Fig. 1). When the axis (as viewed from the base of the shell) is not a solid columella, but instead a cavity is present, nomenclature has been less clear. Previous authors have generally recognized two types of axial openings in gastropod shells: the true umbilicus and the pseudoumbilicus (Fig. 2), but these are not the only forms an axial opening can take. Diagram depicting a cross section of the umbilicate species Euspira catena (da Costa, 1778), modified from Fretter & Graham (1962). Abbreviations: col, columella; umb, umbilicus. A.Stellaria solaris (Linnaeus, 1764) with open umbilicus. B.Hexaplex cichoreum (Gmelin, 1791) with pseudoumbilicus. C.Neverita josephinia (Risso, 1826) with plugged umbilicus. All three images were modified from photos by H. Zell published under a Creative Commons 3.0 (CC BY-SA 3.0) license, modified to remove additional images and standardize the background. An umbilicus in a gastropod shell is widely understood as a “[c]avity or depression formed around [the] shell axis between faces of adaxial walls of whorls” (Cox, 1960: I134). Such a ‘true umbilicus’ can form at either the apical or apertural end of the shell (unless otherwise noted, the term usually refers to the basal or apertural end). An umbilicus may form when the inner walls of the whorls are not in contact with each other (Fig. 2A) (Fretter & Graham, 1962: 20) and, in the coiling parameter system of Raup (1966), D, the distance between the inner or axial margin of the generating curve and the coiling axis, is >0 (Fig. 3). The umbilicus may be open without obstruction or covered to a greater or lesser degree with a u-shaped plug-like extension of the callus known as the funicle. When there is no umbilicus, D = 0. In this condition, the inner walls of the whorls are brought into contact with one another, resulting in a more or less solid central pillar around which the whorls of the shell rotate; this is the columella (Fig. 1). For additional terminology and character states of the axial features, see Supplementary Material Appendix S1; for a list of taxonomic names cited, relevant authorities and references, see Supplementary Material Appendix S2. Gastropod coiling geometry as modelled by Raup (1962). Parameters include the size ratio (W) of successive generating curves (whorl expansion rate), the distance (D) of the generating curve from the axis and the proportion (T) of the height of one generating curve that is covered by each subsequent turn (translation rate). The term ‘pseudoumbilicus’ has unfortunately been used to refer to multiple unrelated shell features. This is likely a result of its ambiguous definition by Cox (1960: I132, fig. 64, I107) as a “[d]epression or cavity in shell base affecting only last whorl.” Most recent authors have used the term to refer to a narrow opening in the anterior columella associated with the callus, adjacent to but separate from, the aperture (Fig. 2B) (e.g. Saul & Popenoe, 1993; Vermeij & Snyder, 2006; Landau & Vermeij, 2012; Couto & Simone, 2019). This feature is structurally unrelated to a true umbilicus. This usage agrees with the term false umbilicus, defined by Knight (1941: 24) as “an indentation close to the columella of an anomphalous shell … [which] suggests an umbilicus but does not pass entirely between the whorls as does a true umbilicus”, but this term has been adopted by fewer authors (see e.g. Palmer, 1937: 292; Kilburn, 1985). A number of fossil and living species in the family Turritellidae possess openings in the basal end of the columellar region that at first appear to be examples of true umbilici, but which on closer examination are structurally distinct morphological features (Fig. 4) that have not been previously recognized or named. Our original observation of this trait occurred during a systematic study on Turritellidae from the Pliocene–Pleistocene of Florida and the Atlantic coastal plain of the USA (Friend et al., 2023). The axial hollow opening was first observed in a large specimen of “Turritella alumensis” Dall, 1892 that (importantly) lacked an apex. Holding the specimen up to a light revealed a hole travelling the entire remaining length of the axis, situated precisely where we expected the columella of turritellids to always occur. In other words, the outermost shell walls (exterior of the shell) formed a tube within which a helical platform coiled, extending from the outer whorl wall inwards, leaving a central column of hollow space. This helical platform is formed as the floor of the aperture, and in columnate taxa, it would connect the columella (inner wall of the whorl) with the outer whorl walls, but in this case, no inner (axial) shell wall is present. The absence of a columella was confirmed when a narrow rod or needle inserted into this opening could be pushed deeper than the height of the final whorl (because the presence of a columella prevents the needle from travelling through more than one whorl). Most of the “Turritella” we examined construct inner shell whorl walls and columellas, but a number of turritellid species were determined to lack both true umbilici and columellas (Supplementary Material Table S1). A. Cut specimen of Turritella terebra (Linnaeus, 1758) revealing the columella, PRI 68583. B. Sectioned specimen of Caviturritella magnasulcus (Petuch, 1991) PRI 40387, showing the absence of a columella. C.Caviturritella magnasulcus (Petuch, 1991), PRI 104745, Pleistocene, Florida. D.Caviturritella alumensis (Mansfield, 1930), PRI 41858, Pliocene, Florida. This opening and the hollow space it produces in gastropod shells do not appear to have been recognized or named before. A comparison to spiral staircases serves to clarify our observations and proposed nomenclature. In architecture, a newel is the term for the central support post or pillar in a spiral staircase. A hollow newel (or open newel) is “an opening in the center of a winding staircase in place of a newel post, the stairs being supported each step by those below, and all held in place by the wall” (https://www.merriam-webster.com/). We therefore propose that the axial openings in these gastropod shells be designated hollow newels (HNs). The presence of an HN is the result of the absence of complete inner shell walls that would otherwise form the columella, or in cases where D > 0, the wall of the umbilicus. Notable spiral staircases with HN designs include the spiral staircase in the Loretto Chapel in Santa Fe, New Mexico, USA: Bernini's spiral staircase at the Basilica di Santa Maria Maggiore in Rome, Italy; and the spiral staircase at the Basilica de la Sagrada Familia in Barcelona, Spain (Fig. 5). In each of these instances, the staircase does not possess a central supporting pillar (the newel post), which is analogous to what in a gastropod would be designated the columella. In each of these staircases, the central space is entirely void, as can be seen when looking up or down through the axial space. Just as one could pass an elongated object through this central opening from the first floor to a point several turns higher on one of these stairways, an object such as a needle can enter the opening at the base of an HN-bearing gastropod shell and make contact with the body chamber several whorls up. This maneuver would be physically impossible in both columella-bearing gastropods and newel postbearing spiral staircases. Image looking down the axis of a hollow newel spiral staircase at the Basilica de la Sagrada Familia, Barcelona, Spain. Staircase stringer is indicated by white line. Modified from a photograph taken by Andrew Smith, used under Creative Commons 2.0 (CC BY-SA 2.0) license. All of the major body retractor muscles in shelled gastropods originate from the columellar muscle, which is the only muscle attached to the calcified shell (Fretter & Graham, 1962; Price, 2003). In coiled gastropods with a columella, this insertion takes place on a single area on the columella of the shell, leaving a muscle scar in some cases. In limpet-form and haliotid gastropods, which have no columella, the muscle inserts on the inside of the shell (Frescura, 1990; Wanninger et al., 1999). In umbilicate gastropods, the muscle is attached to the inner wall of the whorl (Fretter & Graham, 1962; Price, 2003). In a gastropod with an HN instead of a columella, there are at least two potential attachment points for this muscle: (1) the lower or upper part of the c-shaped whorl wall (the floor or ceiling of the staircase, respectively) and (2) the inner edge of the lower or upper part of the c-shaped whorl wall. In staircase architecture, this structure is referred to as the inner “stringer” (Templer, 1992; Tománek & Every, 2017; see Fig. 5); snails with HNs exhibit helical inner stringers, which, although they may at first appear to be warped columellas, actually represent the axial edge of the apertural (basal) portion of each whorl. The complete absence of the inner shell wall, and therefore the columella, exposes this “stringer”, which is not itself a discrete feature of HN-bearing gastropods, but one that would not be noticeable if the generating curve were entire and the base of the shell was contiguous with the inner shell wall (columella). Unlike in architectural terminology where the inner and outer stringers are themselves features of the staircase that are important to maintaining its structural integrity (Tománek & Every, 2017), we are explicitly not ascribing any special status or inferring modified development of the stringer region of HN-bearing shells, but we believe this terminology is useful for describing this anatomical structure formed by helically coiled inner (axial) edge of the shell. In terms of coding this feature for phylogenetic analysis (e.g. Friend et al., 2023), the character agnostically described as ‘axis form’ or ‘newel state’ can be seen to have, at minimum, three character states: (1) columella present, (2) umbilicus present and (3) HN. Additionally, two other states can be meaningfully recognized: (4) columella formed but later resorbed in apical portions of the shell (see Supplementary Material Fig. S1), and (5) hollow columella (where a cavity is present that is closed off from both the body chamber and the outside environment; see Supplementary Material Fig. S2). Diagrams depicting the differences among these states are shown in Figure 6. Schematic representation of the various types of axis states in gastropod shells (see also Supplementary Material Appendix S1). In the triangular shell shapes, black indicates outer shell material and dark grey indicates inner shell wall material. The circles represent the part of the shell that is being observed when viewing the base of each shell. For the purpose of this diagram, the abapical (basal) portion of the whorl is considered ‘outer shell wall’ material. We conducted an exhaustive search of gastropods with this feature in the Paleontological Research Institution (PRI) collection by systematically opening 295 drawers and visually scanning every lot. Specimens appearing to have HNs were probed with a straight pin, and were photographed. Our preliminary survey of nonturritellid gastropods indicates that a number of other taxa (see Supplementary Material Table S2) also have HNs, such as Scaphander lignarius (Linnaeus, 1758) (Supplementary Material Fig. S3). The majority of HN-bearing taxa have much higher whorl expansion rates (W of Raup, 1966), resulting in a larger, wider aperture facilitating examination (e.g. Haliotis). Some HN-bearing taxa (including Sinum concavum (Lamarck 1822)) are characterized as having nonentire apertures, meaning that a ‘gap’ exists in the generating curve at the margin of shell growth (sensuRaup, 1966); it is not a complete circle but rather a reversed ‘c-shape’. In other words, the mantle edge that secretes the shell does not extend a full 360°. Some members of Siliquariidae also have incomplete apertures, generating a longitudinal slit of varying lengths in the teleoconch (Savazzi, 1996). The slit in the shell overlays a corresponding slit in the mantle, which does not produce shell material (Morton, 1951). We can imagine the incomplete aperture of turritellids forming by this pathway, but in turritellids with an HN, the region of nondeposition is axially located and wide enough that the axial wall is not formed. It is intriguing that this evolved in some siliquariids as well as some turritellids, as combined molecular and morphological phylogenies indicate these taxa are closely related (Strong et al., 2011), and this may represent a form of evolutionary parallelism (Pietsch et al., 2020). HN-bearing turritellids remain unique among clades in which the HN condition was found in having relatively high translation rates, low expansion rates and the ability to retract the foot inside the aperture. No nonturritellid high-spired taxa (e.g. species belonging to Terebridae, Mitridae or Cerithiidae) examined as part of our collections survey were found to have the HN state. In turritellids, the HN appears to characterize a clade designated Caviturritella (described in Friend et al., 2023), most of the species of which occur in the western Atlantic and tropical eastern Pacific (see Supplementary Material Fig. S4). The extant species that have this character state for which molecular data are available also all appear to be closely related (Sang et al., 2019; Anderson & Allmon, 2023). The related clade is without HNs, which would suggest the loss of HN is characteristic of the clade. In contrast, the topology present in Bayesian phylogenies produced by Anderson (2018) and Anderson & Allmon (2023), which does not include specimens for which only a single gene is available and represent broader sampling of the Turritellidae, does not require losses to explain the phylogenetic distribution of HNs. Given that HNs occur in many species in the same ocean basin and not elsewhere in other turritellids, including large species, and that molecular evidence indicates that extant species with this character likely form a clade (Supplementary Material Fig. S4), it is most parsimonious to presume that the HN state is a phylogenetically informative character useful for recognizing members of this clade. The formal generic description of this clade, including extant and fossil species, is presented in Friend et al. (2023). In discussing the potential functions of the HN, we focus on turritellids because the HN-bearing non-turritellids differ greatly in morphology and location of muscle attachment. Most of the turritellid species with HNs that we examined have relatively large body sizes and have columellas as juveniles that disappear with age. When compared with co-occurring species, species belonging to Caviturritella generally have wider shells (t-test: t = –2.2294, P < 0.04). The large size of most HN taxa suggests that HNs are one way to attain or maintain large body size—either through cessation of deposition from the mantle segment responsible for its creation or through resorption of columellar shell material soon after formation. The relationship between large size and the presence of the HN may be explained if total calcification is limiting in some way. By not producing an inner shell wall, if the same total amount of shell material were to be produced by the animal in the same amount of time, then spiral growth (along the outer shell wall) and shell axial length would necessarily be greater when compared to a shell that did allocate material towards the production of an inner shell wall. In some HN-bearing taxa, this reallocation of calcification effort may alternatively or simultaneously be employed to thicken the outer shell wall, providing additional protection against predation (e.g. Caviturritella abrupta; Anderson & Allmon, 2020). This may represent a potential tradeoff between the ability to resist crushing predation and the ability to resist drilling or peeling predation (see Allmon et al., 1990), although it is unclear how thickening an outer shell wall and removing the columella would impact failure under compressive stress. We propose two evolutionary scenarios (see Supplementary Material Appendix S3) based upon the functionality (or lack thereof) of HNs. The HN state is distinct from other similar features in that it is the result of nondeposition of inner shell wall rather than a through the distance of the inner shell wall from the axis or resorption (Fig. The HN of a gastropod shell is a and therefore the absence of something, in this the inner shell wall and therefore the columella. Nevertheless, the HN an important structural to the shell as a a that for turritellids appears to be phylogenetically and an umbilicus is a structural and phylogenetically the HN may represent a structural that may be to in some species, or not it (e.g. Anderson & Allmon, a that The of an HN, although itself the absence of shell may be considered a true 2019; unrelated to in shell or in growth as characterized by Raup (1966), the formed is not the result of any growth but instead by an area of nondeposition in the generating in this of shell forming is both and The that the snails are instead forming most of something is but the feature of in this is the hole such as can be to & Varzi, 2019). It is that have been turritellid shells for but have described this several of these species have been the of recent (e.g. Allmon et al., 1992; & Allmon, of both of living and those in an important of that is to molecular and in an of and gastropod taxa described or more can us with features as as a there is the of much remaining to be to and for and/or on of the We H. Zell and Andrew for images that were used herein under Creative Commons This was supported in part by the to

Förderung

  • National Science Foundation

Zitieren

APA

Friend, D. S., Anderson, B. M., & Allmon, W. D. (2024). The hollow newel state in gastropods: when snail shells are open-axis. Journal of Molluscan Studies, 90(1). https://doi.org/10.1093/mollus/eyae001

Vancouver

Friend DS, Anderson BM, Allmon WD. The hollow newel state in gastropods: when snail shells are open-axis. Journal of Molluscan Studies. 2024;90(1). doi:10.1093/mollus/eyae001

BibTeX
@article{Friend2024,
  author = {Friend, Dana S and Anderson, Brendan M and Allmon, Warren D},
  title = {The hollow newel state in gastropods: when snail shells are open-axis},
  journal = {Journal of Molluscan Studies},
  year = {2024},
  volume = {90},
  number = {1},
  doi = {10.1093/mollus/eyae001}
}
Kostenlos starten →