Productivity is not enough: re-establishing the foundations of value in digital health
International Journal for Quality in Health Care · 05.10.2026 · 38 (4)
DOI: 10.1093/intqhc/mzag177 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift International Journal for Quality in Health Care, online erschienen am 29.10.2026. Verfasst von Kathrin Cresswell und 2 weiteren Autor:innen. Beteiligte Einrichtung: Usher Institute, The University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, United Kingdom. Die Arbeit nennt 10 Literaturangaben.
Themen: Digitalisierung in der Pflege
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Almost three decades ago, the Institute of Medicine published To Err is Human: Building a Safer Health System [1]. The report recognized that to be safer, healthcare systems must be redesigned to reduce preventable harm, reframing patient safety as a systems challenge rather than the consequence of individual error. It also acknowledged that unsafe care is inherently inefficient: preventable adverse events result in longer hospital stays, additional treatments, disability, litigation, and avoidable costs. As such, safety and efficiency are presented as complementary goals. Productivity and efficiency (measured as the volume of outputs generated from available inputs and whether those outputs are achieved with optimal use of resources, respectively) have become central policy objectives, as healthcare systems face increasing demand alongside constrained financial and workforce resources [2, 3]. Digital technologies are widely promoted as enablers of both operational and clinical productivity [4]. Operationally, they aim to improve efficiency by streamlining workflows, reducing administrative burden and duplication, and easing demand on resource-intensive services. Clinically, they seek to improve care quality and safety through better access to information and decision support, while improving convenience for patients and healthcare professionals. While productivity is undoubtedly important, the value of technologies extends beyond efficiency and cost savings, encompassing broader improvements in care quality, patient outcomes, safety, and the experiences of patients and healthcare professionals. Policy discourse often frames productivity primarily in terms of economic value through greater efficiency, reduced costs, and increased output [5], contributing to the implicit assumption that productivity gains are synonymous with healthcare value. Recent work has applied the Quintuple Aim (which seeks to improve population health and experience of care, lower per-capita costs, improve workforce wellbeing, and advance health equity) to ambient Artificial Intelligence (AI) scribes, AI-enabled tools that generate clinical documentation from clinician–patient conversations. The authors highlight uneven evidence across the Quintuple Aim domains and state the need for more comprehensive evaluation [6]. Building on this work, we argue that evaluation should also consider how value is defined and experienced within and across domains. This requires moving beyond narrow measures of productivity and economic return towards a broader understanding of healthcare value, and the societal values (i.e. the underlying principles and priorities about what matters in healthcare) that shape it. Value in digital health can be understood from both demand- and supply-side perspectives. Patients, healthcare professionals, organizations, and health systems may experience and prioritize value differently, including the benefits derived from using a technology (‘use value’) and its economic value within markets and systems of provision (‘exchange value’) [7, 8]. Value is therefore not an inherent property of digital technologies but is socially constructed [9], emerging through judgements about which outcomes matter, for whom, and what trade-offs are considered acceptable. Many evaluations of healthcare digitalization privilege what is readily measurable, potentially overlooking processes, mechanisms, and unintended consequences that are more difficult to quantify [10]. Assessing value therefore requires combining quantitative outcome measures with qualitative approaches that capture how value is experienced by different stakeholders and explore how it emerges in practice. Ambient AI scribes illustrate this challenge. Building on Tierney and colleagues’ assessment across the Quintuple Aim [6], we apply this broader conceptualization of value to consider who benefits, what forms of value are created, and potential tensions and trade-offs across Quintuple Aim domains (Box 1). Applying a broader value lens to current evidence on ambient AI scribes. Patients and populations: improved health outcomes and potentially greater access to care. Organizations and health systems: greater capacity to support preventive care, chronic disease management, and population health. Use value: improved information and clinician capacity may support better health outcomes. Exchange value: improved outcomes and reduced avoidable utilization may generate economic value. Public value: improved population health and stewardship of healthcare resources. Patients: personalized care, improved communication, continuity, and clinician attentiveness. Organizations: improved patient experience and quality of care. Use value: improved clinician–patient interaction and accessible clinical information may support better care. Exchange value: improved patient experience may contribute to organizational value. Public value: person-centred healthcare. Patients: greater healthcare capacity may improve access and reduce waiting times. Organizations and health systems: reduced documentation burden, greater productivity, and lower costs. Use value: reduced administrative burden may release clinician capacity. Exchange value: productivity gains may generate economic value through increased activity and reduced costs. Public value: greater efficiency may support stewardship of public resources. Healthcare professionals: reduced documentation burden and potentially improved wellbeing. Organizations: improved retention, recruitment, and workforce sustainability. Use value: reduced administrative burden and improved clinician experience. Exchange value: improved workforce performance and reduced turnover may create organizational and economic value. Public value: workforce wellbeing contributes to a resilient and sustainable health system. Patients and populations: equitable access, performance, and benefit across different languages, disabilities, socioeconomic circumstances, and other characteristics. Organizations and health systems: equitable implementation across patient groups and settings. Use value: equitable benefit across diverse patient populations. Exchange value: commercial incentives may affect which populations and settings receive access. Public value: reducing rather than widening health inequalities. Productivity gains from ambient AI scribes are increasingly evident, but their overall healthcare value remains uncertain. Evaluating ambient AI scribes through a value lens therefore moves the focus beyond whether they improve individual Quintuple Aim outcomes towards who benefits, what forms of value are created, and what trade-offs may arise across domains. This can support more informed implementation and procurement decisions while guarding against privileging readily measurable productivity gains over less visible forms of value for patients, healthcare professionals, organizations, and health systems. None declared. None declared. No new data were generated or analysed in support of this research.
Autor:innen und Institutionen
- Usher Institute, The University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, United Kingdom.
- Science of Care Institute & Lunenfeld-Tanenbaum Research Institute, Sinai Health; Institute of Health Policy, Management and Evaluation, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
- Artificial Intelligence and Digital Health, Institute for Evidence-Based Healthcare, Faculty of Health Sciences & Medicine, Bond University, Gold Coast, Queensland, Australia.
Zitieren
APA
Cresswell, K., Steele Gray, C., & Iqbal, U. (2026). Productivity is not enough: re-establishing the foundations of value in digital health. International Journal for Quality in Health Care, 38(4). https://doi.org/10.1093/intqhc/mzag177
Vancouver
Cresswell K, Steele Gray C, Iqbal U. Productivity is not enough: re-establishing the foundations of value in digital health. International Journal for Quality in Health Care. 2026;38(4). doi:10.1093/intqhc/mzag177
BibTeX
@article{Cresswell2026,
author = {Cresswell, Kathrin and Steele Gray, Carolyn and Iqbal, Usman},
title = {Productivity is not enough: re-establishing the foundations of value in digital health},
journal = {International Journal for Quality in Health Care},
year = {2026},
volume = {38},
number = {4},
doi = {10.1093/intqhc/mzag177}
}
EUVIMED