When courts fall silent, societies descend into darkness: Judicial resilience, legal empowerment, and the struggle against autocracy
International Journal of Constitutional Law · 01.04.2026 · 24 (2) · 395-411
DOI: 10.1093/icon/moag071 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift International Journal of Constitutional Law, online erschienen am 03.07.2026. Verfasst von Justice (R) Syed Mansoor Ali Shah.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
This address, delivered at the NYU Research Symposium on Legal Empowerment & Autocracy in Accra, Ghana, in March 2026, examines why judicial independence collapses under autocracy and what legal, institutional, and cultural resources are required to resist that collapse. Drawing on the author’s resignation from the Supreme Court of Pakistan following the Twenty-Sixth and Twenty-Seventh Constitutional Amendments—which dismantled judicial independence through formally democratic procedures—the speech argues that twenty-first-century autocracy operates not by abolishing constitutional forms but by hollowing them from within, a phenomenon the literature identifies as autocratic legalism. The address distinguishes formal from substantive democracy, drawing on Aharon Barak’s jurisprudence and the African constitutional tradition articulated by Dean Atuguba, to argue that substantive democracy—grounded in dignity, equality, and the welfare of all citizens as a duty of the state—is structurally incompatible with autocratic governance. It then presents a comparative study of Ghana and Pakistan: two postcolonial states sharing a common legal inheritance that produced radically divergent outcomes in judicial resilience. Ghana’s judiciary, forged in the aftermath of the 1982 murder of three High Court judges, developed the institutional identity, professional solidarity, and constitutional culture necessary to hold. Pakistan’s judiciary, conditioned by a colonial culture of institutional apoliticism, repeatedly capitulated—validating successive military interventions through an expanding doctrine of necessity. Drawing on Lisa Hilbink’s study of Chilean judges under Pinochet and Lawrence Baum’s audience theory, the speech identifies four drivers of judicial capitulation: fear, comfort, isolation, and—most critically—a professional culture that frames constitutional guardianship as impermissible political action. It argues that judicial independence is not a character trait but an institutional condition, and proposes a six-dimensional framework for legal empowerment of the constitutional court: doctrinal empowerment, including the basic structure doctrine; structural empowerment; professional empowerment through mobilized bar associations; epistemic empowerment through reformed legal education; democratic empowerment through an activated citizenry; and a selection imperative that prioritizes demonstrated constitutional character over technical competence alone. The address further argues that the culture of resistance—poetry, literature, music, and art—is not supplementary to but constitutive of the moral imagination required to sustain legal resistance under autocracy. Drawing on figures from Faiz Ahmed Faiz to Steve Biko, and from Pablo Neruda to Ngũgĩ wa Thiong’o, it proposes that the formation of constitutional court judges should include immersion in the global tradition of resistance. The speech concludes with a defense of principled resignation as a form of constitutional resistance, grounded in the moral philosophy of Dworkin, Fuller, Arendt, and Radbruch, and offers a six-point roadmap for rebuilding judicial resilience: reforming legal education, redesigning judicial selection, protecting bar associations, maintaining strategic litigation under captured courts, building international solidarity networks, and sustaining the cultural foundations of democratic conviction.
Zitieren
APA
Shah, J. R. S. M. A. (2026). When courts fall silent, societies descend into darkness: Judicial resilience, legal empowerment, and the struggle against autocracy. International Journal of Constitutional Law, 24(2), 395-411. https://doi.org/10.1093/icon/moag071
Vancouver
Shah JRSMA. When courts fall silent, societies descend into darkness: Judicial resilience, legal empowerment, and the struggle against autocracy. International Journal of Constitutional Law. 2026;24(2):395-411. doi:10.1093/icon/moag071
BibTeX
@article{Shah2026,
author = {Shah, Justice (R) Syed Mansoor Ali},
title = {When courts fall silent, societies descend into darkness: Judicial resilience, legal empowerment, and the struggle against autocracy},
journal = {International Journal of Constitutional Law},
year = {2026},
volume = {24},
number = {2},
pages = {395--411},
doi = {10.1093/icon/moag071}
}
EUVIMED