L26/P-378 “I don’t want to be someone’s dirty little secret”: normative framings and donor-conceived experiences of insemination fraud
Human Reproduction · 01.07.2026 · 41 (Supplement_1)
DOI: 10.1093/humrep/deag083.712 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Human Reproduction, online erschienen am 08.07.2026. Verfasst von S. Zeghiche und 2 weiteren Autor:innen.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Study question How does the normative framing of insemination fraud (IF) in academic literature align with donor-conceived individuals’ experiences and interpretations of this form of reproductive misconduct? Summary answer IF is primarily framed as physician wrongdoing through a legal lens, while donor-conceived individuals describe overlooked harms related to identity, kinship, and moral recognition. What is known already Insemination fraud (IF) refers to the non-consensual substitution of gametes used in insemination by a health professional. Although an increasing number of cases have been revealed through direct-to-consumer genetic testing over the past decade, IF remains marginal in academic literature. Existing scholarship has primarily examined IF through legal analyses of medical malpractice, breach of trust, and informed consent. Ethical discussions remain limited and largely derivative of legal reasoning, focusing narrowly on patient autonomy and professional duties. Empirical research on lived experiences is scarce, particularly the perspectives of donor-conceived individuals, despite the profound personal and relational consequences of discovering IF. Study design, size, duration This paper combines an argument-based scoping review of normative academic literature with a qualitative empirical study. The review synthesized ethical and legal arguments across 18 peer-reviewed articles published up to 2025. From the gaps identified, a preliminary ethical framework for IF was developed. Concurrently, the empirical strand involved in-depth semi-structured interviews with 21 donor-conceived adults affected by IF, drawn from a larger qualitative dataset collected in 2021–2022 as part of a broader research project. Participants/materials, setting, methods The scoping review followed Arksey and O’Malley’s framework, integrating argument-based analysis to map normative claims across disciplines. Qualitative data were collected through online interviews with donor-conceived adults from North America, South America, and Europe, recruited via purposive and snowball sampling. Interview transcripts were thematically analyzed using NVivo, combining inductive and deductive coding within a life course perspective. The Mapping-Framing-Shaping approach (Huxtable & Ives 2019) guided the integration of normative analysis with experiential data. Main results and the role of chance The scoping review revealed a predominantly legal framing of insemination fraud, focused on physician misconduct, breach of fiduciary duties, and failures of informed consent. Ethical analysis was largely confined to principle-centered interpretations of autonomy and professional responsibility, with minimal engagement with relational, identity-based, or intergenerational harms. Donor-conceived individuals were rarely recognized as moral subjects in their own right, reflecting broader legal challenges related to standing, the non-identity problem, and wrongful life claims. The qualitative findings sharply contrasted with this framing. Participants described insemination fraud as a biographical rupture, producing enduring ethical harms related to identity coherence, kinship disruption, loss of trust in medicine, and moral injury – extending well beyond the violation of parental consent. Discovery often entailed a “double revelation” of donor conception and fraud, compounding distress. While individual experiences varied, participants consistently articulated a sense of injustice not reducible to their parents’ violated consent, emphasizing the moral relevance of genealogical truth, relational autonomy, and recognition. Limitations, reasons for caution The literature reviewed remains largely US-centered, limiting cross-jurisdictional comparisons. The qualitative sample, while international, is not statistically representative and reflects self-selected participants willing to discuss IF. In addition, interviews were conducted retrospectively, which may shape narratives of harm. Findings are therefore analytically rather than numerically generalizable. Wider implications of the findings Integrating normative analysis with lived experiences has allowed researchers to move beyond physician-centered legal approaches toward an ethical framework recognizing harms to donor-conceived individuals and their parents. The findings support ethical, legal, and policy responses that center these voices, particularly as direct-to-consumer genetic testing continues to reveal previously hidden cases. Trial registration number No
Zitieren
APA
Zeghiche, S., Cassou, M., & Couture, V. (2026). L26/P-378 “I don’t want to be someone’s dirty little secret”: normative framings and donor-conceived experiences of insemination fraud. Human Reproduction, 41(Supplement_1). https://doi.org/10.1093/humrep/deag083.712
Vancouver
Zeghiche S, Cassou M, Couture V. L26/P-378 “I don’t want to be someone’s dirty little secret”: normative framings and donor-conceived experiences of insemination fraud. Human Reproduction. 2026;41(Supplement_1). doi:10.1093/humrep/deag083.712
BibTeX
@article{Zeghiche2026,
author = {Zeghiche, S. and Cassou, M. and Couture, V.},
title = {L26/P-378 “I don’t want to be someone’s dirty little secret”: normative framings and donor-conceived experiences of insemination fraud},
journal = {Human Reproduction},
year = {2026},
volume = {41},
number = {Supplement_1},
doi = {10.1093/humrep/deag083.712}
}
EUVIMED