L26/P-889 Measuring what matters in IVF: a mathematical modelling of why commonly reported success metrics fail to reflect patient-centred outcomes and what should we measure instead
Human Reproduction · 01.07.2026 · 41 (Supplement_1)
DOI: 10.1093/humrep/deag083.1213 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Human Reproduction, online erschienen am 08.07.2026. Verfasst von C. Hickman und 8 weiteren Autor:innen.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Study question Do traditional IVF measures of success align with patient-centred outcomes, and how do operational practices distort them? Summary answer Traditional IVF success metrics are manipulable and misaligned with patient interests; live birth per patient, time, cost and convenience to babies are preferred metrics. What is known already IVF clinic performance is benchmarked using KPIs reported by national registries, commonly per embryo transfer, per cycle, per egg collection, or per embryo transferred. While easy to calculate, these metrics fail to capture cumulative success, patient burden, or overall clinical and financial efficiency. They are highly sensitive to clinical strategies such as selective transfers and PGT-A, masking operational deficiencies including poor stimulation, fertilisation, or blastulation rates. Consequently, reported success often misrepresents patient experience and incentivises practices that prioritise metrics over outcomes. HFEA has revised definitions five times, causing substantial ranking shifts and confusion for patients and professionals. Study design, size, duration We reviewed national registry reporting practices and PubMed literature, then applied dual mathematical models simulating 28 London clinics using the HFEA choose a Fertility clinic metrics. The first model assessed how clinical strategies affected standard KPIs; the second evaluated sensitivity to operational deficiencies. Metrics were analysed over multiple cycles and patient scenarios to identify which measures most accurately reflected patient-centred outcomes. Participants/materials, setting, methods Traditional IVF success metrics were assessed for alignment with patient needs, sensitivity to operational failures, simplicity, reporting speed, &resistance to manipulation. Modelling simulated identical lab capabilities while varying clinical strategies, including PGT-A, selective embryo transfer, stimulation protocols. Live birth per new patient and cost-to-baby were evaluated for cumulative success, efficiency, and patient experience. Rankings of 28 London clinics were compared across these metrics and correlated with HFEA inspection ratings, Google reviews, HFEA patient experience scores Main results and the role of chance Traditional per-transfer and per-collection KPIs performed poorly across all criteria, failing to capture operational inefficiencies and being highly susceptible to strategic manipulation. Practices such as discarding viable embryos, selective patient exclusion, and staged transfers artificially inflated metrics while reducing cumulative live birth chances and increasing patient burden. Clinic rankings shifted dramatically depending on success metric definitions, demonstrating low correlation between per-egg collection and per-embryo transfer metrics, and no correlation with Google review scores or inspection ratings. In contrast, live birth per new patient per defined period (LBPPOT) was resilient to clinical strategy, rewarded efficient technology use, and reflected operational competence. Larger clinics showed more negative patient experiences correlated with high-volume cycles, highlighting limitations of current metrics. Modelling confirmed that patient-centred success metrics align incentives with outcomes that matter to patients, including total live birth, cost, time, and convenience to baby, rather than isolated procedural statistics Limitations, reasons for caution Capturing cost-to-baby data in the HFEA registry requires legal change. Current success metrics are confusing and inconsistent, with PGTA included or excluded arbitrarily. Transparent, patient-centred metrics are needed to clearly reflect outcomes that truly matter to patients. Wider implications of the findings Regulators and clinics must prioritise cumulative live birth, time-to-baby, and cost-to-baby. Patient-centred metrics discourage manipulative practices, reward true operational excellence, and ensure innovations deliver real value. How we measure success shapes what we achieve—transforming IVF from numbers on a page to meaningful outcomes that truly matter to patients. Trial registration number No
Zitieren
APA
Hickman, C., Ruiz, J., Cardenas, D., Duran, M., Hall, V., Illiev, D., Ruso, H., Odia, R., & Popa, T. (2026). L26/P-889 Measuring what matters in IVF: a mathematical modelling of why commonly reported success metrics fail to reflect patient-centred outcomes and what should we measure instead. Human Reproduction, 41(Supplement_1). https://doi.org/10.1093/humrep/deag083.1213
Vancouver
Hickman C, Ruiz J, Cardenas D, Duran M, Hall V, Illiev D, et al. L26/P-889 Measuring what matters in IVF: a mathematical modelling of why commonly reported success metrics fail to reflect patient-centred outcomes and what should we measure instead. Human Reproduction. 2026;41(Supplement_1). doi:10.1093/humrep/deag083.1213
BibTeX
@article{Hickman2026,
author = {Hickman, C. and Ruiz, J. and Cardenas, D. and Duran, M. and Hall, V. and Illiev, D. and Ruso, H. and Odia, R. and Popa, T.},
title = {L26/P-889 Measuring what matters in IVF: a mathematical modelling of why commonly reported success metrics fail to reflect patient-centred outcomes and what should we measure instead},
journal = {Human Reproduction},
year = {2026},
volume = {41},
number = {Supplement_1},
doi = {10.1093/humrep/deag083.1213}
}
EUVIMED