EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Crossref

The Dark Side of 3D Simulation in Breast Augmentation: How to Use Its Advantages and Avoid Its Drawbacks

Paolo Montemurro, Luca Savani iD, Paolo Toninello iD

Aesthetic Surgery Journal · 17.03.2025 · 45 (4) · NP129-NP131

DOI: 10.1093/asj/sjae245 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Aesthetic Surgery Journal, online erschienen am 19.12.2024. Verfasst von Paolo Montemurro und 2 weiteren Autor:innen. Die Arbeit wurde bisher 9-mal zitiert (Crossref) und nennt 5 Literaturangaben.

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

We read the article “Optimizing Implant Width Selection in Breast Augmentation: Insights From On-Patient Landmark Positioning in 3-Dimensional Breast Simulation” by Isil Akgun Demir with interest. The author described a method to make 3D simulation with the Vectra XT imaging system more reliable, underlying the advantages of this tool, but also suggesting that it is not free of drawbacks and pitfalls.1 After many years of using 3D simulation, we agree that it is crucial not to completely rely on technology—physical measurements and surgeon's experience remain the most reliable tools. Furthermore, over time, we noticed that 3D simulation is even less useful in some specific cases, which deserve particular consideration. We introduced 3D simulation into our process for breast augmentation in 2008,2 and reported our enthusiastic experience in 2013.3 As also noted by Creasman et al,4 the senior author's conversion rate significantly increased after this tool was introduced into his practice; most patients claimed to prefer clinics which offered 3D technology, and reported that the simulation was accurate and helped them in choosing the implant.3 Also, the idea that the surgeon is using the latest technology can help to engage patients. Undoubtedly, 3D simulation has been a significant step forward regarding preoperative consultation for breast augmentation. However, if misused, it can become counterproductive for both patient and surgeon. Although some studies reported the accuracy of computer simulation for volume assessment of breast augmentation as being greater than 88%, there are some aspects to consider in this regard.3,5 First, most 3D simulation systems tend to adjust the shape of the breast to the chest regardless of the actual width of the implant because the software is set up to show an optimally filled breast (Figure 1). For instance, implants with a 14-cm base would in reality never fit properly into a patient with a 12-cm-wide breast, whereas 3D simulation significantly mitigates this discrepancy. Using a Vectra M3 system, Roostaeian and Adams found that the least accurate simulations were when patients chose an implant 50 cc greater than the optimal volume based on preoperative measurements.5 Therefore, in our opinion, virtual reality should never be used as an “implant catalog” or a “virtual fitting room” because a patient might be pleased with the simulation of an implant that is not suitable for her. Three-dimensional simulation of breast augmentation depicted on a 31-year-old female patient. (A) Preoperative image, (B) simulation with the proper implant according to preoperative assessment, and (C) simulation with a much larger (475 cc) implant. Although the 475-cc implant would be completely out of proportion for this patient, the software adapts the volume to the chest, making the result unrealistically beautiful. In Akgun Demir's opinion, Vectra's automatic landmark positioning tends to be more accurate in patients with thinner breast tissue and an exposed inframammary fold than in those with thick and big breasts, ptosis, and chest deformities.1 Similarly, in our experience, small breasts with no ptosis or asymmetries are the most suited for 3D simulation (Figure 2). On the other hand, we would like to underline some particular cases in which 3D simulation can easily become counterproductive, showing a result that is much worse than the actual outcome. A 29-year-old female patient with small breasts with no ptosis or asymmetries and normal intermammary width. (A) Preoperative image, (B) 3D simulation of postoperative result, (C) actual result 1 year after breast augmentation with the same implant shown in the simulation. The 3D simulation was able to predict the result accurately. This might happen with particular anatomical situations that significantly differ from the average, such as patients with a wide intermammary space (Figure 3) or with an emptied upper pole (typical of women after pregnancies) (Figure 4), or patients with pseudoptotic breasts (Figure 5). In these instances the picture generated by the computer is not accurate and will certainly not be helpful. In these cases, we deem it advisable not to show the simulation to the patient at all, because once they see it, they cannot unsee it, and they might therefore choose not to go ahead and have surgery because they believe their result will not be good. A 35-year-old female patient with a wide intermammary distance. (A) Preoperative image, (B) 3D simulation of postoperative result, (C) actual result 1 year after breast augmentation with the same implant shown in the simulation. The 3D simulation was not able to display the actual improvement of the cleavage. A 38-year-old female patient with emptied upper pole. (A) Preoperative image, (B) 3D simulation of postoperative result, (C) actual result 1 year after breast augmentation with the same implant shown in the simulation. The 3D simulation was not able to display the actual improvement in the upper pole of the breast. A 41-year-old patient with a pseudoptosis. (A) Preoperative image, (B) 3D simulation of postoperative result, (C) actual result 1 year after breast augmentation with the same implant shown in the simulation. The 3D simulation was not able to foresee the rising of the breast over the implant, giving a “stiff and pointy” image of the breast. Furthermore, we found that the nipple-areola complex is the area of the breast for which virtual reality is least reliable. In surgery, the implant fills out the tissue, stretching wrinkles or folds of the nipple-areola complex. However, the simulation software is often not able to foresee these changes and can show larger breasts with a larger and creased areola.2 For all these reasons, we strongly believe that the proper use of virtual reality should be as a final complement of the following process: (1) select a small range of implants according to anthropometric features; (2) choose one and make the patient try sizers within a sport bra; (3) show a 3D simulation with the chosen implant to help the patient further visualize the result. We deem it crucial not to show simulations of implants that are not suitable for the patient because the software might generate a picture that looks good and make the patient desire that size. We also advise not to try and simulate breasts with an anatomy that the imaging system cannot generate a suitable picture of. Dr Montemurro is a consultant and speaker for POLYTECH Health & Aesthetics GmbH (Dieburg, Germany). Drs Savani and Toninello have no disclosures. The authors received no financial support for the research, authorship, and publication of this article.

Autor:innen und Institutionen

ORCID-Profile: Luca Savani, Paolo Toninello

Zitieren

APA

Montemurro, P., Savani, L., & Toninello, P. (2025). The Dark Side of 3D Simulation in Breast Augmentation: How to Use Its Advantages and Avoid Its Drawbacks. Aesthetic Surgery Journal, 45(4), NP129-NP131. https://doi.org/10.1093/asj/sjae245

Vancouver

Montemurro P, Savani L, Toninello P. The Dark Side of 3D Simulation in Breast Augmentation: How to Use Its Advantages and Avoid Its Drawbacks. Aesthetic Surgery Journal. 2025;45(4):NP129-NP131. doi:10.1093/asj/sjae245

BibTeX
@article{Montemurro2025,
  author = {Montemurro, Paolo and Savani, Luca and Toninello, Paolo},
  title = {The Dark Side of 3D Simulation in Breast Augmentation: How to Use Its Advantages and Avoid Its Drawbacks},
  journal = {Aesthetic Surgery Journal},
  year = {2025},
  volume = {45},
  number = {4},
  pages = {NP129--NP131},
  doi = {10.1093/asj/sjae245}
}
Kostenlos starten →