Lack of challenge to substantive criteria at mental health tribunals: Amplifying the medical perspective?
International Journal of Law and Psychiatry · 2026
DOI: 10.1016/j.ijlp.2025.102166 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift International Journal of Law and Psychiatry, 2026. Verfasst von Sam Boyle und 3 weiteren Autor:innen. Beteiligte Einrichtung: Queensland University of Technology School of Law, Australian Centre for Health Law Research, George St, Brisbane 4000, Australia. Electronic address…. Hauptthemen laut MEDLINE: Mental Competency, Commitment of Persons with Psychiatric Disorders, Mental Disorders. Die Arbeit nennt 33 Literaturangaben. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0). Gefördert von: Saint Lawrence College.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Mental health tribunals provide legal safeguards for compulsory treatment for mental illness. Despite one of these tribunals' purposes being to give people subject to compulsory treatment a "day in court", research has shown that individuals' experience of mental health tribunals is highly negative. To understand these negative experiences, we conducted a multi-stakeholder study of the Consent and Capacity Board, a mental health tribunal in Ontario, Canada. Our research revealed that disputes in the hearings tended to focus on procedural requirements of the compulsory treatment orders, and although substantive legal criteria were addressed, the medical conclusions underlying those criteria were not directly challenged. Further, in cases where a client "wins" and the treatment order is revoked, our analysis shows the medical perspective remained authoritative. Finally, although people subject to treatment orders were given a chance to speak at hearings, in most cases theirs was the only voice challenging the psychiatrist's medical conclusions, and their contribution would usually only lessen the chance of the order being revoked. Therefore, we argue that rather than challenging medical decision-making, as may be expected, tribunal hearings unintentionally amplify the medical perspective in a manner that is likely to be upsetting for people subject to the treatment orders. We acknowledge that this effect is ingrained in the current system and will be challenging to ameliorate. Nonetheless, it is an important consideration for those in legal and clinical practice, and policy makers. We give some suggestions about how these experiences could be improved and for further research opportunities.
Schlagwörter
MeSH-Schlagwörter (MEDLINE)
Stichwörter der Autor:innen
Autor:innen und Institutionen
- Queensland University of Technology School of Law, Australian Centre for Health Law Research, George St, Brisbane 4000, Australia. Electronic address: samuel.boyle@qut.edu.au.
- St. Lawrence College School of Nursing, 2288 Parkedale Avenue, Brockville, ON K6V 5X3, Canada. Electronic address: fjager@sl.on.ca.
- School of Nursing, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Ottawa, 200 Lees Avenue, Ottawa, ON K1N 6N5, Canada. Electronic address: jdoming2@uottawa.ca.
- School of Nursing, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Ottawa, 200 Lees Avenue, Ottawa, ON K1N 6N5, Canada. Electronic address: amelie.perron@uottawa.ca.
Förderung
- Saint Lawrence College
Zitieren
APA
Boyle, S., Jager, F., Domingue, J. L., & Perron, A. (2026). Lack of challenge to substantive criteria at mental health tribunals: Amplifying the medical perspective?. International Journal of Law and Psychiatry. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijlp.2025.102166
Vancouver
Boyle S, Jager F, Domingue JL, Perron A. Lack of challenge to substantive criteria at mental health tribunals: Amplifying the medical perspective?. International Journal of Law and Psychiatry. 2026. doi:10.1016/j.ijlp.2025.102166
BibTeX
@article{Boyle2026,
author = {Boyle, Sam and Jager, Fiona and Domingue, Jean-Laurent and Perron, Amélie},
title = {Lack of challenge to substantive criteria at mental health tribunals: Amplifying the medical perspective?},
journal = {International Journal of Law and Psychiatry},
year = {2026},
doi = {10.1016/j.ijlp.2025.102166}
}
EUVIMED