One Step from Harm: Adverse Event Patterns in External Prosthetic Knee Components
PM&R · 2026-11 · 18 (S3)
DOI: 10.1002/pmrj.53_70259 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift PM&R, online erschienen am 10.11.2026. Verfasst von Matthew Smith und 1 weiteren Autor:innen.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Background and/or Objectives: Several meta-analyses have shown that exercise is effective in treating symptoms of depression, and at least as effective as the established frontline treatments (second-generation antidepressant drugs, psychotherapy).Consequently, in the last 15 years, exercise was introduced in clinical-practice guidelines in several countries as an evidence-based option for the treatment of subthreshold, mild, and moderate depression.The introduction of a non-commercial, possibly free alternative in a market long dominated by commercial, for-profit options (pharmacotherapy, psychotherapy) creates potentially fertile conditions for the emergence of anti-exercise bias in clinical research literature.This may be especially noticeable in meta-analyses.Therefore, in this critical appraisal, we sought concrete indications of anti-exercise bias in one of these meta-analyses (cited over 1600 times) that, unlike the bulk of the published evidence, concluded that exercise is ineffective in treating depression.
Design
We critically appraised data entry, inclusion and exclusion criteria, and what constituted a notreatment "control" group within the randomized controlled trials included in the meta-analysis.
Setting
Empiric research.
Participants
None.
Interventions
Critical appraisal of studies included in the meta analysis.Main Outcome Measures: Our findings indicate multiple errors and biases that systematically devalued the antidepressant effects of exercise.Several studies included "no-treatment" controls which compared other active interventions, artificially diminishing the observed effect of exercise.
Results
Several of the studies compared exercise to other active interventions such as milder forms of exercise or stress management which is not no-treatment or placebo.We discovered 5 papers in this meta-analysis that did not meet criteria for randomized controlled trial, and one with data entry error.
Conclusions
We believe these methodological errors should exclude these randomized controlled trials from a high quality meta analysis and bias the analysis against exercise.Mischaracterization of these studies with good scientific methodology puts the validity and accuracy of the paper in question.We intend to rework the meta analysis data as invalid.
Zitieren
APA
Smith, M., & Tiu, T. (2026). One Step from Harm: Adverse Event Patterns in External Prosthetic Knee Components. PM&R, 18(S3). https://doi.org/10.1002/pmrj.53_70259
Vancouver
Smith M, Tiu T. One Step from Harm: Adverse Event Patterns in External Prosthetic Knee Components. PM&R. 2026;18(S3). doi:10.1002/pmrj.53_70259
BibTeX
@article{Smith2026,
author = {Smith, Matthew and Tiu, Timothy},
title = {One Step from Harm: Adverse Event Patterns in External Prosthetic Knee Components},
journal = {PM&R},
year = {2026},
volume = {18},
number = {S3},
doi = {10.1002/pmrj.53_70259}
}
EUVIMED