EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
EditorialSystematische Übersicht

Post‐diagnosis adiposity, physical activity, dietary factors and cancer survival: A systematic review of the evidence base (WCRF Global Cancer Update Programme)

Rudolf Kaaks iD

International Journal of Cancer · 2024

DOI: 10.1002/ijc.34958 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Editorial in der Zeitschrift International Journal of Cancer, 2024. Verfasst von Rudolf Kaaks. Beteiligte Einrichtung: Division of Cancer Epidemiology, German Cancer Research Center (DKFZ), Heidelberg, Germany. Hauptthemen laut MEDLINE: Adiposity, Exercise, Neoplasms. Die Arbeit wurde bisher 3-mal zitiert (Crossref) und nennt 10 Literaturangaben.

AbstractSchlagwörterBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

Epidemiologic observations of widely divergent cancer incidence rates worldwide gave the impulse to decades of epidemiologic research, with thousands of case–control and prospective cohort studies, to examine the impact of diet, physical activity and excess body weight on cancer risk and mortality. Since the 1990s, the World Cancer Research Fund (WCRF)—a charity active in the United Kingdom, the Netherlands and the United States—took up a central role in organizing international expert reviews to summarize the evidence from this research, resulting in the publication of Expert Reports in 1997, 2007 and 2017. While the 1997 report was still largely based on findings from ecologic and case-control studies, the 2007 report included evidence more predominantly from prospective cohort analyses, leading to more reliable recommendations on body weight, physical inactivity and diet in relation to cancer risk. After 2007, WCRF funded scientists at the Imperial College, London, to perform a series of reviews and meta-analysis to continue updating the available evidence from a growing body of data from prospective cohort studies. The findings of this Continuous Update Project (CUP) culminated in a third Expert Report, published in 2018, which assessed evidence for cancers at 17 organ sites and largely confirmed the conclusions and global public health recommendations already reached 10 years earlier. WCRF's major public health recommendations1 are: to maintain a healthy body weight, to be physically active, to limit alcohol consumption, to eat wholegrains, vegetables, fruit and beans and limit sugar-sweetened drinks, limit consumption of red and processed meat, and avoid use of dietary supplements for cancer prevention purposes. For cancer survivors, WCRF so far suggested following the same recommendations as for cancer prevention. In 2021, WCRF launched its international Global Cancer Update Program ('CUP Global'), as extension of the Continuous Update Project ('CUP'). One of the priorities for CUP Global is to expand its research and evaluations to nutritional recommendations for cancer patients, in view of more specific and evidence-based recommendations for optimizing nutritional lifestyle after cancer diagnosis. In this journal, as part of CUP Global, researchers at Imperial College London, supported by large international expert teams, published two series of comprehensive reviews and meta-analyses on the associations of post-diagnosis adiposity, physical activity, sedentary behavior and dietary factors with prognostic outcomes among patients with (female) breast cancer and patients with colorectal cancer. For both cancer sites, hundreds of studies were examined and reviewed according to a pre-published protocol, focusing on longitudinal observational studies and randomized clinical trials (RCTs). For each evaluation report, the international expert teams graded the quality of the studies reviewed, using version 2 of the Cochrane risk-of-bias tool for RCTs, and a modified version of the Risk of Bias for Nutrition Observational Studies tool. Meta-analyses were conducted with great care for detail, including the evaluation of linear as well as non-linear dose-response models, and sub-group analyses, for example, by tumor stage, or after exclusion of patients with metastatic disease. For breast cancer, 225 reports from longitudinal studies, comprising more than 456,000 women with breast cancer, provided evidence for J-shaped relationships between body mass index (BMI) and all-cause and breast cancer specific mortality. These relationships indicated better survival in women of high-normal to low-overweight BMI, but increased risk of second primary breast cancer, breast cancer-specific mortality and all-cause mortality among more severely overweight or obese women, as well among low-normal to underweight women, and these relationships were judged to be likely causal. By contrast, studies showed only limited/suggestive evidence for a relationship between body fatness and breast cancer recurrence and non-breast cancer related mortality.2 Likewise, 20 longitudinal observational studies plus three small RCTs provided only limited/suggestive evidence for a possible inverse relationship of breast cancer-specific mortality with recreational physical activity,3 and a total of 108 studies showed only limited/suggestive evidence for reduced risk of breast cancer in relation to healthy food consumption patterns, intake or serum levels of isoflavones, dietary fiber intake, or serum 25(OH)D concentrations.4 For colorectal cancer, 124 longitudinal observational studies comprising >294,000 patients suggested a possible non-linear association between post-diagnosis BMI and risk of all-cause mortality, colorectal cancer-specific mortality and recurrence/disease-free survival, with lowest risk at a BMI of 28 kg/m2, and increased risks for patients with BMI 32 kg/m2. However, due to concerns about possible biases the evidence for possible causality of these relationships was judged to be limited/inconclusive.5 Furthermore, the summary of 16 longitudinal observational studies, comprising 82,220 individuals with colorectal cancer, suggested only limited/suggestive evidence for a weak inverse association between recreational physical activity and all-cause mortality or recurrence/disease-free survival,6 and a total of 69 publications from five RCTs and 35 observational studies also provided only limited/suggestive evidence for possible associations between healthy dietary patterns (high in plant-based foods, whole grains, coffee; low in sugary drinks) and lower all-cause mortality.7 Overall, based on the above evidence, the authors concluded that breast cancer patients should be encouraged to avoid obesity and be physically active if able and fit with their specific medical advice.8 For colorectal cancer patients the authors concluded that the outcomes of their reviews, although only graded as limited-suggestive, might nonetheless be used to guide colorectal cancer patients towards a physically active lifestyle and a diet rich in plant-based foods, intake of whole grain foods and coffee, but avoiding sugary drinks, as ways to potentially improve overall survival.9 The major aim of the present syntheses was to strengthen the evidence base for recommendations as whether modification of the nutrition-related lifestyle or risk factors could likely have a positive impact on recurrence-free and/or overall survival of patients with cancers of the breast or large bowel. This motivated the investigators to focus the reviews exclusively on studies in which BMI, physical activity or diet and supplement use had been assessed after cancer diagnosis. However, while large numbers of studies were available for review, covering very large numbers of cancer patients and health-related outcomes, the overall quality of evidence was rated as relatively low, not allowing clear conclusions of causality for associations observed. Most of the available evidence arose from studies of a purely observational (i.e., non-experimental/non-randomized) nature, and the authors pointed to the high risk of possible biases due to, amongst others, reverse causality (i.e., changes in diet, physical activity or body weight as a result of disease or its treatments), residual confounding (e.g., by pre-cancer exposures, disease subtype & stage, cancer treatment), inaccurate exposure measurements (e.g., using BMI as approximate adiposity measure; limited detail in ascertainment of physical activity patterns; exposure assessments in most studies only at one point in time, ranging from immediately after diagnosis to many years post-diagnosis), or also selection bias (inclusion only of patients with some accumulated survival time). Only very few relevant RCTs for lifestyle interventions were identified. Particularly noteworthy is that the majority of studies examined did not directly inform as to whether changes in the lifestyle-related factors after cancer diagnosis (e.g., intentional weight loss, increases in physical activity in previously sedentary patients, or changes in diet) would likely have a positive and measurable impact on health outcomes. Most of the evidence reviewed pertains to associations of longitudinal health outcomes with ascertainments of these lifestyle-related factors at a single time after cancer diagnosis, but not on their subsequent (intentional or non-intentional) changes. Moreover, some of the associations considered, for example, for excess body weight, could have been largely a reflection of nutritional states (e.g., body weight) before cancer diagnosis.10 In the latter case, the findings of the present CUP Global reviews could also be interpreted as confirmation of WCRFs recommendations to the general public, for cancer prevention. In summary, while the WCRF and the research teams in charge of the CUP Global evaluations are to be commended for their continuing efforts of summarizing findings from nutritional epidemiology studies, setting highest possible standards for scientific evaluation, their present reviews in IJC suggest that available study evidence does not allow strong nutritional recommendations specifically for cancer patients. In particular, due to a lack of controlled and large-scale intervention studies, there is limited or insufficient evidence showing whether, or not, voluntary weight loss (for obese or overweight patients), increases in physical activity or changes in diet after cancer diagnosis can have additional, beneficial effects on overall health outcomes. Thus, one of the major conclusions of the reviews, underscored also by the authors, is that, to strengthen the evidence that tailored lifestyle modifications might improve health outcomes and overall survivorship in patients with breast or colorectal cancers large-scale RCTs would be needed, as well as large and well-designed observational studies with more accurate, repeated information about exposures and potential confounders at multiple times after, and preferably also before, cancer diagnosis.

Schlagwörter

MeSH-Schlagwörter (MEDLINE)

AdiposityExerciseNeoplasmsHumansDietSystematic Reviews as Topic

Autor:innen und Institutionen

  • Division of Cancer Epidemiology, German Cancer Research Center (DKFZ), Heidelberg, Germany.

ORCID-Profile: Rudolf Kaaks

Zitieren

APA

Kaaks, R. (2024). Post‐diagnosis adiposity, physical activity, dietary factors and cancer survival: A systematic review of the evidence base (WCRF Global Cancer Update Programme). International Journal of Cancer. https://doi.org/10.1002/ijc.34958

Vancouver

Kaaks R. Post‐diagnosis adiposity, physical activity, dietary factors and cancer survival: A systematic review of the evidence base (WCRF Global Cancer Update Programme). International Journal of Cancer. 2024. doi:10.1002/ijc.34958

BibTeX
@article{Kaaks2024,
  author = {Kaaks, Rudolf},
  title = {Post‐diagnosis adiposity, physical activity, dietary factors and cancer survival: A systematic review of the evidence base (WCRF Global Cancer Update Programme)},
  journal = {International Journal of Cancer},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1002/ijc.34958}
}
Kostenlos starten →