Birth: From obscurity to hot topic
The Anatomical Record · 20.05.2026
DOI: 10.1002/ar.70225 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift The Anatomical Record, online erschienen am 20.05.2026. Verfasst von Karen Rosenberg und 1 weiteren Autor:innen. Beteiligte Einrichtung: Department of Anthropology, University of Delaware, Newark, Delaware, USA. Die Arbeit nennt 47 Literaturangaben.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Biological anthropology is rooted in evolutionary theory. When you consider that much of the discipline's research is focused on factors that alter reproductive success, it is shocking that little scholarly attention was paid to the evolutionary context of birth until the middle of the last century. Consider how much research has gone into measuring primate canine size, with regard to its contribution to the reproductive success of males. Other common topics in biological anthropology that are also under selection include such characteristics as nasal morphology, browridge form, hidden estrus, length of childhood, and the role of grandmothers. Certainly, such aspects of human morphology, physiology, life history, and behavior contribute to reproductive success. We would argue, however, that there is no point in the human life course where the forces of natural selection operate with such intensity as the time of birth. In one moment, two human lives and their lifelong health are at stake, and what happens at the time of birth has a strong impact on their future reproductive success, up to and including complete elimination of their genes. Furthermore, we know that this has occurred throughout human history, and that the childbearing years were always a time of significant morbidity and mortality for young women and their babies. Such intense selection is rarely true of canine size, nose shape, or browridge development, in which selection, of course, occurs but in much more subtle and less obvious ways. The power of natural selection is illustrated so graphically by childbirth that it is a persuasive example to use in explaining human evolution to undergraduates or the general public. Furthermore, everyone has had direct or indirect experience with childbirth and has probably thought about the risks associated with it, even if they have not thought about it in the context of natural selection. Given its clear impact on fitness, why did research on childbirth come so late to biological anthropology? When people learn that we do research on human birth, one of the first questions they ask is “why does birth have to be so painful and so complicated?” The two of us, Karen Rosenberg and Wenda Trevathan, have devoted much of our careers to answering that question. The focus of our research over the last decades has been the unusual way in which humans give birth, how it got that way, and how humans have met the challenges birth presents. For much of this time, we have built on the proposal of Washburn (1960) and others that birth difficulties arise in association with the evolution of bipedal locomotion and brain expansion. In Washburn's view (see Figure 1), these two distinctive human traits are in conflict with each other during the birth process and present what he referred to as an obstetrical dilemma resulting from selection for a small pelvis for bipedal locomotion but a spacious pelvis to accommodate the large-brained neonate. He proposed that this dilemma was resolved by delivering babies when they are small and “at a much earlier stage of development.” Solving the obstetrical dilemma by giving birth to less-developed (and therefore more helpless) infants was possible according to Washburn only because of behavioral adaptations that enabled the mother and her social network to care for the infant. Washburn's proposal was that bipedal locomotion, encephalization, and the developmental status of the infant explain the centrality of culture, which included tool use, sexual division of labor, and the origin of the family. Washburn's discussion of the obstetrical dilemma appeared in a somewhat obscure paragraph in an article written for the general public in Scientific American. Birth was not the central focus of the article, and he did not develop the idea any further in his writings, as far as we know. It was so obscure that even in a book devoted entirely to the evolution of human birth (Trevathan, 1987), Wenda did not cite this phrase or the paper. This is not to suggest that pelvic adaptations for childbirth were ignored by scholars in biological anthropology. Although the phrase “obstetrical dilemma,” was not used, the concept that human pelvic morphology represents a compromise between obstetrical capaciousness and locomotor efficiency was implicit in the work of Schultz (1969), Lovejoy, Heiple and Burstein (1973), Leutenegger (1974, 1982, 1987), Abitbol (1987, 1988, 1996), Lovejoy (1988), Tague and Lovejoy (1986), and Trevathan (1987, 1988), among others. In fact, the phrase itself was not used again in an evolutionary context for 32 years after Washburn's first use, when Karen resurrected it in her 1992 Yearbook paper (Rosenberg, 1992), reviewing the evolution of modern human childbirth. Sometime after that, use of the phrase became much more common (see Figure 2). As can be seen by the diverse papers in this volume and many others, the idea is still at the core of a great deal of research and writing. Wenda's interest in birth was triggered by an American Anthropological Association (AAA) conference symposium on childbirth (“Birth and Interaction”) that she attended as a graduate student in 1975, which had MDs and cultural anthropologists as participants. Hearing these papers, she realized that biological anthropology had overlooked childbirth as an important aspect of the human adaptation. Anatomists and human paleontologists had occasionally discussed pelvic morphology associated with birth, based on fossil remains or comparative anatomy, but they rarely considered the social or behavioral adaptations to the resulting obstetrical challenge. Wenda realized she had the basis of a dissertation topic involving biobehavioral and evolutionary aspects of childbirth. This was in the mid-1970s when much research done on the role of females in human evolution focused on challenges to “man the hunter” ideas (Lee & DeVore, 1966), pointing out that women also made important economic contributions to the family as producers of resources (Tanner & Zihlman, 1976, Zihlman, 1978). Women as reproducers was not central to the discussion. For this reason, members of Wenda's dissertation committee advised against doing research on women's reproductive roles because it was not part of the waves of feminist scholarship happening elsewhere in Anthropology. Feminist anthropologists at the time focused more on showing how women's roles were similar to and equal to men's and not on the unique things that women do. Nevertheless, she persisted, and went on to train as a midwife as part of her dissertation research. Given the outstanding papers in this volume and research published elsewhere devoted to this topic, she is very glad that she didn't listen to her advisors. Karen began her career studying Neandertals and was particularly interested in the characteristic of the elongated pubic bone that had been pointed to as a feature distinguishing Neandertals from modern humans and considered a uniquely derived trait in that lineage, but which seemed to be related to birth canal size. She argued that the elongated pubic bone was related to a larger birth canal in Neandertals that was, in turn, an adaptation for giving birth to their larger babies. She proposed that although Neandertals were outside the modern range of variation, they followed the same pattern as living humans. Her interest in the evolution of childbirth arose from this initial interest in Neandertal pelvic morphology. In 1985, Wenda organized a symposium (with Helen Fisher) about the evolution of human childbirth (“Birth in Biocultural Perspective”) at an AAA meeting, including scholars who took comparative, paleontological, and behavioral perspectives. Karen, who was still writing her dissertation and pregnant with her first child, was one of the participants in that symposium. The organizers and participants were delighted at the number of people who attended, which was far greater than one normally sees at a biological anthropology session at the AAA meetings. Karen was particularly excited (and intimidated) to note that Sherwood Washburn himself was sitting in the front row! In fact, we have noticed that when childbirth is the subject, the audience is always large and engaged. Again this raises the question of why it took biological anthropologists so long to address the topic of birth. Helen and Wenda's symposium, which is where we met, marks the birth of our joint research. Since that time, the focus of our collaborations has been understanding the interrelationship of the characteristics that Washburn wrote about: locomotion, encephalization, helpless newborns, and the family, and how these led to birth being a social event for hominins. Our first joint symposium devoted to this topic was held at an American Association of Physical Anthropology meetings in 1994, entitled “Birth and Infancy in Human Evolution.” In 1995, we wrote a paper that revisited Washburn's concept of an obstetrical dilemma (Rosenberg & Trevathan, 1995). We agreed that the constraints of bipedalism, in conjunction with large brains, meant that human babies are more immature at birth than our non-bipedal relatives. We focused on the mechanism of birth in humans, which typically involves rotation of the fetus through a tight birth canal and emergence in an occiput anterior presentation, in ways quite different from other primates. This complex mechanism placed a premium on having assistance at birth, as Wenda had observed in her midwifery training and discussed in two earlier publications (Trevathan, 1987, 1988). Human females benefitted from having social support from others and she proposed that humans were unusual mammals because they were dependent on what she called “obligate midwifery.” Karen, based on her observations as a paleoanthropologist, added perspectives on the antiquity of the modern human pattern of childbirth and the complex and mosaic way it evolved with a particular focus on what obstetricians call the cardinal movements of labor, that is, rotational birth and emergence facing away from the mother. We proposed that the benefits of assisted birth could be traced to the origin of bipedalism, long before encephalization (Rosenberg & Trevathan, 2001, 2002). Recently there have been suggestions that the “obstetrical dilemma” as originally proposed by Washburn is not a useful concept for understanding human birth with some scholars questioning its very existence (Dunsworth, 2018, 2021; Dunsworth et al., 2012). We know a lot about human evolution today that Washburn didn't know. He didn't know as much as we do about the relative chronology of bipedalism, encephalization, and tool use. He didn't know that a wide pelvis is the primitive condition for bipeds. He did not have access to some very important specimens in the human fossil record that we have today, including Lucy (A.L. 288-1) (Tague & Lovejoy, 1986), Gona (Ruff, 2010; Simpson et al., 2008, 2014), Nariokotome (WT 15000) (Ruff, 1995; Walker & Ruff, 1993), Kebara MH 2 (Rak & Arensburg, 1987) and new reconstructions of the Tabun Neandertal specimen (Ponce de León et al. 2008, Weaver & Hublin, 2009). He didn't know that human newborns have probably been large relative to maternal body size for much of human evolution (DeSilva, 2011). He certainly didn't have access to the sophisticated analytical methodology that is available to scholars today. Despite the limitations and simplicity of his model, Washburn's proposal has led to a wealth of research, much of which is discussed in this volume. One of the assumptions implicit in the obstetrical dilemma hypothesis that has led to criticism is the idea that because female pelvic morphology is under direct selection for greater width due to childbirth, it is less efficient for locomotion compared to males. This claim has led some to assume that the female pelvis is compromised for walking when compared to males. To the contrary, several scholars have argued that “male” pelvic morphology, which includes a smaller pelvic canal than “female” is not biomechanically more efficient. In fact, recent work by a range of scholars (Gruss et al., 2017; Gruss & Schmitt, 2015; Rak, 1991, 1993; Wall-Scheffler, 2012; Wall-Scheffler & Myers, 2017) suggests that a wide pelvis may actually be advantageous, allowing flexibility during walking and stability for carrying loads—something that is particularly important for females when they are pregnant or carrying children. Another morphological constraint on the pelvis beyond locomotion has been suggested by Stansfield et al. (2021) who focus their work on understanding the relationship between pelvic dimensions and the muscles that support the pelvic floor and internal organs. In general, larger pelvic dimensions that would allow for easier birth compromise support of the pelvic floor, providing another feature that represents antagonistic selection and poses an obstetrical dilemma. Other scholars have challenged Washburn's explanation for the developmental state of the infant at birth (and therefore birth timing). In a 2012 paper, Dunsworth et al. suggested that obstetrical challenges and the state of the human newborn can be explained not by anatomical limits, but by limits imposed on maternal metabolism by the energy-hungry developing fetus. In their view, human babies are born when their energy needs outstrip the ability of maternal metabolism to support further gestation, resulting in babies with immature brains and thus smaller heads. We agree that metabolic constraints are important in birth timing but do not think this contradicts the importance of morphological constraints (Grunstra et al., 2023, Rosenberg & Trevathan 2021). Although controversy over the role of pelvic constraints in human birth continues, we and others agree that it should remain part of the discussion about why human birth is complicated and risky. As Grunstra et al. argue (Grunstra et al., 2023: 540), “fetal size, maternal metabolic investment, and pelvic canal size very likely coevolved because they all needed to fit.” In other words, these ideas about selection on the pelvis are not mutually exclusive. In addition, there are certainly factors that are part of contemporary lifestyles, including diet and activity levels that add to the picture of obstetric complications. Dietary changes since the origins of agriculture and modern diets high in processed foods have led to larger babies (Wells et al., 2012). Undernutrition continues to contribute to compromised birth canals (Wells et al., 2024). Increasing medical interventions into birth have contributed significantly to the risks of childbirth (Stone, 2016; Walrath, 2017). Sedentary lifestyles and elective surgical deliveries (Rosenberg & Trevathan, 2018; Trevathan, 2010) also add to the list of obstetrical compromises. In the past 60 years, the focus on childbirth in human evolution has moved from an afterthought in Washburn's paper on the importance of tool use to a central role in understanding both the evolution of human females and the evolution of the species as a whole. Our work builds on the concept of the obstetrical dilemma to argue that modern human birth is a biocultural event that benefits from assistance, ranging from the presence of a supportive person to advanced technological medical intervention. The evolutionary perspective on human birth reinforces the idea that, in most cases, birth is a normal event that may be more complicated today because of inappropriate medical intervention and contemporary lifestyles. Although birthing technology certainly has benefits in many cases, medical intervention has also come at great costs to physical, emotional, and social well-being. Nicole Torres-Tomayo and Cedric Cordey launched a new phase of research on this important topic by bringing together a diverse group of scholars working on many different aspects of the obstetrical dilemma in a symposium at the American Association of Biological Anthropology meetings in Baltimore in 2025 (The Evolution of Birth Difficulties: Interdisciplinary Approaches to the “Obstetrical Dilemma”). This symposium stimulated conversation among a large audience, indicating the ongoing powerful draw of this topic. Many of the papers from that symposium form the core of this special issue of The Anatomical Record. We are excited to see those papers and the research reported in this volume and hope that they illustrate the value of an evolutionary perspective in obstetrics and that they can point to ways to achieve a better balance between the benefits of clinical intervention and the value of emotional support. Despite the challenges to Washburn's original simple model, we and many others think that the obstetrical dilemma is still a useful concept. It has clearly been a springboard for a wealth of research in human biology and evolution, testing and challenging Washburn's original model and subsequent development of it. Controversies swirling around the obstetrical dilemma have contributed to a further explosion of research, as exemplified by the papers in this volume, which address aspects of soft tissue anatomy, metabolic constraints, sex differences in the pelvis, comparative anatomy, developmental state of the human at birth, locomotor adaptations, thermoregulation, and other previously ignored sources of selection on the pelvis. The papers in this volume illustrate the breadth and depth of this important work showing that the research has taken the field in widely divergent directions focusing on many different aspects of this complex, but critical event in human life history. Regardless of why the study of birth came so late to biological anthropology, we are delighted that today it is at the center of so much exciting cutting-edge research that offers new ways of thinking about the evolution of human childbirth.
Autor:innen und Institutionen
- Department of Anthropology, University of Delaware, Newark, Delaware, USA.
- School for Advanced Research, Santa Fe, New Mexico, USA.
ORCID-Profile: Karen Rosenberg
Zitieren
APA
Rosenberg, K., & Trevathan, W. (2026). Birth: From obscurity to hot topic. The Anatomical Record. https://doi.org/10.1002/ar.70225
Vancouver
Rosenberg K, Trevathan W. Birth: From obscurity to hot topic. The Anatomical Record. 2026. doi:10.1002/ar.70225
BibTeX
@article{Rosenberg2026,
author = {Rosenberg, Karen and Trevathan, Wenda},
title = {Birth: From obscurity to hot topic},
journal = {The Anatomical Record},
year = {2026},
doi = {10.1002/ar.70225}
}
EUVIMED